SciFi Question of the Day: In the SciFi you’ve read and watched, what role does religion play? Is it treated as a quaint, backwards practice or as an integral aspect of an enlightened future?
Facebook Answers
Didva Zachariel Ruthk religion is usually a reason for aggression or a tool for subjugation.
Janine Gorell I thought Gene Roddenberry and Rod Serling interposed moral/ethical dilemmas perhaps due to their religious background which I share and recognized, which made watching, for me, less scary.
Gwendolyn Wilkins ”Crash Landing on Iduna” was probably the most religious sci-fi I’ve ever read (at least that comes to mind).
Asimov and Anne McCaffrey tended to avoid religion and they’re the bulk of my scholarly repertoire.
I actually enjoyed the concept of the Children of the Mind of Christ in the Speaker for the Dead series branch-off of Orson Scott Card’s Ender’s Game.
Janine Gorell Farenheit 451 was supposedly based on a hyperbole of book burning by the Nazi’s and what would happen if the Nazi’s were successful at banning independent thought and putting propoganda in its place. Does your question contemplate that?
Janine Gorell So, in the case of Farenheit 451 a world without religion would be a hellish place.
Cayla Ray A lot of sci-fi seems to ignore religion in the human characters, but does go into descriptions of alien religions. I think this may be because it is safer not to alienate fanbase by portraying their religions in certain ways, but correlaries can be drawn more neutrally in the ‘alien’ rules and rituals of religion.
Daniel Beard I am reminded of the basis of religion in Heinlein’s “Stranger in a Strange Land”. “Thou art god”. nothing more, nothing less
Daniel Beard I am also reminded that Heinlein and Hubbard had a bet going as to which could create an actual religion base on one of their books. Hubbard won.
Google Plus Answers
Rebecca Blain – Honestly, I can’t think of a single SciFi i have read recently that has included religion at all. It has all been politics.
Jenn Thorson – All I can think of is Logan’s Run. There, their beliefs about being reborn are killing everyone over, what 19? I wouldn’t say that fits in either the quaint or enlightened categories.
Does “the force” in Star Wars count? Rebecca Blain – +AmyBeth Inverness I don’t view the force as a religion. It is a force, a power, just like magic is a tool used by sorcerers. I don’t view sorcery as religion, and the force is just a magic or tool used by jedi and sith imho. Jedi and sith, also, come across as politic groups in their general approach. They don’t worship anything.
AmyBeth Inverness – +Jenn Thorson First, thank you for the perfect example of the correct use of there and their. I’d call the Logan’s Run practice barbaric… an example of an atrocity performed for reasons that no longer exist, for the sake of religion.
Jennifer R. Povey – I’ve noticed a tendency for science fiction writers to actively avoid religion. Some writers do claim that we outgrow it. Star Trek shows non-human religions, but not human ones. Rebecca Blain – +AmyBeth Inverness I guess to some, politics is religion :3
JoJo Zawawi – Not all religions include worship. Nevertheless, they deal with man as a spiritual being and are therefore religions by definition. A religion does not need to include worship in order to be a religion.
Sam Webb – Weber touches on it a bit in the Honor Harrington series. Now I’m reading his Safehold series and the use/misuse of religion is an integral part of the story.
Jenn Thorson – Ha, you’re welcome– happy homonyms to you. 🙂 (PS- I recently committed an atrocity on “shoot” instead of “chute.” When I found it, I wanted to shoot myself and send myself down the chute. 🙂
Mario Gutierrez – Philip K. Dick’s Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? (aka Blade Runner) — Mercerism.
David Foster – ST: Deep Space 9 made a valient effort. It has often irked me religion is casually erased from society. There are some breif mentions in Ender’s Game, but that is nearly present day, so I don’t know if that counts. StarGate SG-1 had worship, but mainly of parasites with delusions of grandeur. BSG (classic and new) had some religion.
AmyBeth Inverness – In my own writing, I usually include religion as a regular part of most, but not all character’s lives. It’s not overwhelming, it’s just another part of their very involved lives.
But one of my favorite stories is Nightfall by Silverberg & Asimov. Spoiler Alert the religion is purposely formed by those who know better because, post apocalypse, the masses of humanity need something to turn to, and a religious government would provide the necessary stability.
It was an interesting concept. I certainly don’t believe that all religion is false (quite the contrary) but this was an interesting theory.
Jennifer R. Povey – Nightfall. Been forever since I read that story…I’d forgotten that detail. I’ve been reading a lot of Analogs lately and people are certainly not afraid to address religion, alien or human.
Simon Newby – +Jenn Thorson has my comment. Firefly definitely has Religion rubbing up alongside secularity as it does today in places such as the UK. AmyBeth Inverness – In Firefly, they seem to have it around, but most of the crew isn’t sure what exactly to do with Book. Except for River, who cuts and pastes him Bible back together to “fix” it… Simon Newby – Religion seems to be just getting on by in the general universe though. There are various denominations, people join if they feel the need, or not as they see fit. My ideal version of god personally.
I would love to hear what you think! Even if you are reading this post a year or more after publishing, I hope you will leave a comment with your own ideas on this topic.
The previous SciFi Q of the Day is Release the Kraken
The shortlink for this post is http://wp.me/p1qnT4-BQ
The next SciFi Q of the Day is Why Go to the Moon?
Pingback: SciFi Q of the Day: Release the Kraken! | AmyBeth Inverness
Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind. The only real valuable thing is intuition. Reality is merely an illusion, albeit a very persistent one. —Albert Einstein
Great quote!
Why is Science and fiction always a perfect tandem ? But you can never see Fiction associated with Religion. There is no term such as Fiction Religion lol…Because Religion is always considered sacred and truthful and one shining example is Christianity
so whatever you say against it …will always be……science fiction LOL ( go atheists go..go scifi !!! )
I have difficulty working religion into writing as anything other than a political institution. Perhaps I’m merely thinking too deeply in this, but ultimately within a work of art, the artist is god. If the characters worship the artist, this becomes a fourth wall breaking endeavor in ego stroking. If they worship anything else they’re religion is usually provably false, or at least incomplete. There is none of the ambiguity that allows the great questions surrounding religion within fiction, for there is certainly a god.
Because of this, I can only imagine writing about the religions that people would create in absence of truth. And while those religions may have some edifying qualities, they ultimately boil back down to politics.
I think there are two very different ways for religion to appear in a story set in the future. In one, the writer extrapolates a current religion, and either has it seem much the same, or makes a reasonable guess as to a plausible future for that spiritual tradition. In the other, the writer creates a completely new religion, either a human one that may have roots in the religions we are familiar with today, or an alien one that may be completely strange and foreign to us.
I dislike stories that extrapolate the theme of “There is no religion” implying that humans matured beyond the need for God. I think there will always be Atheists, but there will always be the spiritually minded as well,
Pingback: On the Road Again… or Was That a Wagon? | AmyBeth Inverness
Pingback: SciFi Q of the Day: Why Go to the Moon? | AmyBeth Inverness